Banks Are Getting Stricter on Loans – How Captive Finance Can Help Home Improvement Contractors

In recent months, many Americans have felt the squeeze when seeking loans. If you’ve noticed banks being pickier, especially if your credit score isn’t perfect, you’re not imagining it. U.S. banks are under pressure, and that means tighter lending standards in a climate of financial uncertainty. Why is this happening, and what can home improvement contractors do about it? Let’s break it down in a conversational (yet informative) way.

Why Banks Are Tightening Their Lending

Banks are dealing with big financial headwinds. A key issue is that banks sit on hundreds of billions of dollars in “unrealized losses” from their investment portfolios. Essentially, the bonds and securities they bought have dropped in market value because of rising interest rates. By the end of 2024, U.S. banks held roughly $482.4 billion in unrealized losses on securities – a jump of 32.5% in one quarter. To put that into perspective, that’s almost as high as the losses seen during the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) collapse in early 2023. Experts are alarmed that these mounting losses, combined with other economic stresses, could trigger another banking crisis.

Why do these paper losses matter? For one, they make banks nervous. Banks know that if too many depositors or investors lose confidence, any whiff of bad news could spark a panic. As one finance professor warned, “All it takes is one bad news story about any of these banks, and we could have another banking crisis like we had in March 2023”. Basically, banks remember how a surge in withdrawals sank SVB, and they’re keen to avoid a repeat. That means shoring up balance sheets and being extra cautious about new loans.

Interest rates and economic jitters are adding fuel to the fire. Bank losses have been closely tracking the ups and downs of the 10-year Treasury yield. When interest rates rise, bond prices fall, increasing those unrealized losses. In 2025, the 10-year yield has been volatile (even exceeding 4.5% recently) due to factors like new tariffs and stubborn inflation. One Stanford professor noted that at current yield levels, the banking system is already “seeing serious problems”, and if the 10-year yield hits 5%, it “becomes quite bad”. In fact, analysts estimate that a 5% yield could swell bank losses to $600–$700 billion. On top of that, there’s talk of stagflation – a mix of high inflation and slow growth, which could spell higher default risks. As the chief economist of Apollo Global Management cautioned, in a stagflation scenario, “rates will be higher for longer and credit losses will begin to accumulate”, especially on riskier loans.

All of this spooks banks. When banks see trouble on the horizon, they tighten their belts. A Federal Reserve survey confirms what you might suspect: lending standards have been tightening. In late 2024, a notable share of banks reported making their loan criteria stricter for businesses and households. Banks cited “economic uncertainty… and a reduced tolerance for risk” as reasons for clamping down. In plainer terms, banks are becoming more picky about who they lend to, preferring only the safest bets. If you’re a borrower with a less-than-stellar credit score or a newer business without a long financial history, you might find the bank’s door harder to open than before.

‍

The Impact on Home Improvement Loans (and Your Customers)

You might wonder: “Okay, banks are nervous – but how does that affect me as a home improvement contractor?” It turns out, the ripple effects are very real. Home improvement projects often rely on financing. Not every homeowner has tens of thousands in cash ready for a kitchen remodel or a new roof. Traditionally, a homeowner with decent credit might get a personal loan or home equity line from a bank to fund such projects. But if banks tighten up, fewer of those loans get approved. That means fewer customers can afford your big projects, especially those with only fair or poor credit. It can become a frustrating scenario: the homeowner needs the upgrade, you’re ready to do the work, but the financing falls through because the bank said no.

In fact, many homeowners already shy away from bank loans, even before this latest crunch. According to a 2024 Forbes Advisor survey, nearly 63% of U.S. homeowners ended up using their savings to pay for home improvement projects. Loans were only the third-most popular funding source. Just 9% used a personal loan, and about 12% used home equity financing to cover renovations. Why so low? One reason is that interest rates have been high, making loans more expensive. Another is that not everyone can qualify easily – a problem that could worsen as banks get stricter. When three out of five homeowners are doing projects with cash on hand, it suggests many people either don’t want to take on debt or couldn’t get approved for affordable financing.

Now, consider the outlook if the economy slows or if those banking losses keep piling up. Lenders might pull back even more. A recent industry analysis noted that if economic conditions worsen (say, due to higher tariffs or a recession), borrowers may postpone significant home improvements, and lenders may tighten underwriting standards further. It’s a double whammy: consumers hold off on projects, and loans become harder for contractors, translating to fewer jobs on the calendar.

This is a tough spot: you want to grow your business and help homeowners improve their homes, but the financing piece, largely out of your control, is throwing a wrench. If banks tell your customer “no loan for you,” the deal can fall apart even if the customer truly wants the project. Is there anything you can do? Actually, yes. This is where thinking outside the traditional bank box can make a huge difference. Enter captive finance.

What Is Captive Finance?

Imagine if, instead of sending your customers to a third-party bank for a loan, you could offer financing options at the point of sale. That’s essentially what captive finance is. In simple terms, a captive finance company is a lender that’s owned by (or partnered with) a business to finance that business’s customers. If you’ve ever bought a car and financed it through “Toyota Financial Services” or “Ford Credit” rather than a bank, you’ve used a captive lender. The auto dealer didn’t send you to Chase or Bank of America – they provided (or arranged) the loan through their affiliated financing arm. The same concept can apply to other industries, including home improvement.

For a home improvement contractor, setting up a captive lending program means that when a homeowner wants to finance a project, the financing is offered under your company’s umbrella (even if the money ultimately comes from a partner behind the scenes). To the customer, it feels like you’re giving them a one-stop shop: they can get their new HVAC system or kitchen remodel and pay over time, directly through your company.

Why bother with captive lender financing? There are some big potential benefits for your business:

1. More Control Over Financing Terms: You get to define the loan offerings – for example, you might offer a promotional 0% interest plan for 6 months to encourage sales, or set the interest rate and repayment period in a way that suits your customers. Being the one to set (or influence) the terms means you can craft financing deals that help close more sales. You’re not at the mercy of whatever terms a bank would offer (or whether they’d approve the loan at all). In other words, you become the boss of the lending process, rather than a bystander.
   
   
2. A Better Customer Experience: Keeping financing in-house creates a seamless experience. Instead of sending a homeowner off to find a loan at a bank (which might have its priorities and a slow process), you handle it within your own process. This is convenient and builds trust. The customer isn’t dealing with a third party that might confuse or even scare them off with a pile of paperwork. They continue dealing with your team, under your brand, from start to finish. It’s like giving your customers a warm handshake instead of handing them off to someone else. That kind of smooth journey breeds loyalty – the customer is more likely to return for future projects or refer friends, because you made everything easy.
   
   
3. Higher Approval Rates (More Sales): Traditional lenders often have one-size-fits-all criteria. If a borrower falls outside the box (say, a slightly lower credit score), it’s an automatic decline. But with a captive finance program, you can customize underwriting to your customer base. For instance, if you know your typical customer has a 640 credit score and you’ve seen that they still reliably pay for home improvements, you could adjust the credit criteria to approve more of them (within safe limits). By tailoring programs around your customers, you increase approvals and engagement, meaning more of those on-the-fence projects get the green light—more approvals = more jobs for you, without relying on a bank’s rigid rules.
   
   
4. Deep Data Insights: Every loan you make (or facilitate) generates valuable data. You’ll start to see patterns: what types of projects people finance most, how different promotional offers impact acceptance, what payment plans work best, etc. With a captive lending setup, you “own” that customer behavior and credit performance data. This is a goldmine for refining your marketing and sales. For example, if data shows customers are more likely to opt for a bathroom remodel if a 12-month same-as-cash financing is available, you can use that insight in your sales strategy. Data is power; in this case, it stays with you rather than with a bank.
   
   
5. Additional Revenue Stream: Possibly one of the biggest draws – you can earn money from financing. Typically, if a bank or third-party lender provides a loan to your customer, they earn the interest and fees. Often, as the contractor, you might even pay a “dealer fee” to the lender to provide that loan (standard in many point-of-sale financing programs). But what if you could capture those fees and interest as income? Captive finance makes that possible. Instead of waving goodbye to those earnings, you transform what would have been a cost into profit. FinMkt notes merchants can turn those dealer fees into a new revenue stream by keeping financing in-house. In essence, you’re making money from the project itself and financing the project – a double win.
   
   

These advantages sound great – and they are – but we should also acknowledge the challenges. Launching a full-fledged captive finance company isn’t a walk in the park. Traditionally, to start offering loans yourself, you’d need to navigate a maze of regulations (state lending licenses, compliance with federal lending laws, etc.), significant capital to fund the loans, or a way to secure funding. You also take on the risk of borrowers defaulting. Large corporations (like auto makers or retail giants) have done it because they have deep pockets and financial expertise. That level of complexity and risk might sound daunting for a typical home improvement contractor. The good news is, you don’t have to do it alone or build a finance arm from scratch in your garage. There are solutions to help you reap the benefits of captive lending without all the headaches.

‍

‍

Making Captive Lending Easy (How FinMkt Can Help)

This is where FinMkt’s CaptivLend solution comes into play. FinMkt is a fintech company specializing in helping businesses (like home improvement enterprises) offer financing to their customers, essentially enabling “captive” lending programs in a turnkey way. The goal is to let you enjoy all those benefits we discussed, while FinMkt handles the heavy lifting behind the scenes.

How does it work? Think of FinMkt as your new financing program's infrastructure and support system. Here are some key ways FinMkt helps home improvement contractors create a captive lender program:

• They provide the platform, you retain control. FinMkt’s technology platform becomes the engine that powers loan applications, approvals, and servicing, but it’s fully branded as your company. Your customers don’t feel like they were passed off to some third party; the financing offer stays embedded in your website or sales process, maintaining your brand’s look and feel. You get to keep the customer journey in-house and control the user experience, strengthening your brand loyalty.
  
  
• Compliance and regulatory burdens are handled. One of the scariest parts of offering loans is ensuring you follow all the lending laws and regulations. FinMkt steps in here by providing built-in compliance features and even partnerships with banks. In fact, loans can originate from FinMkt’s partner banks, meaning you don’t need your lending license or charter to start offering financing. FinMkt also has things like automatic identity verification, fraud checks, and document e-signature flows that are ready. They’ve essentially done the homework so that you can plug and play.
  
  
• Funding is provided by third parties. Recall the big hurdle: who fronts the money for the loans? FinMkt’s CaptivLend model solves this elegantly. Loans are funded by third-party capital providers who agree to predefined credit criteria. In plain English, FinMkt connects your program with external funding sources (like lenders or investors) that supply the loan funds under the terms you want to offer. You’re not tying up your cash to fund a $20,000 bathroom remodel loan – the capital comes from elsewhere. Because those capital partners have agreed on the credit box up front, approvals can happen quickly, and deployment is rapid. Meanwhile, FinMkt manages the operational and regulatory workload. You get the benefits of being a lender without needing a giant pile of money or a compliance department.
  
  
• Real-time control of credit policy and offers. Through FinMkt’s platform, you can easily tweak your financing programs as needed. For instance, if market conditions change (say, banks tighten and you want to be more selective too), you can adjust the credit score cutoff or the loan terms in real time. Conversely, if you're going to run a promotion – maybe a “summer home upgrade” financing special with no payments for 3 months – you can configure that on the fly. FinMkt lets you dynamically adjust credit criteria, terms, and promotions so your financing offer is always aligned with your business strategy and economic climate. Big banks often lack this agility, but you can have it.
  
  
• Data and analytics at your fingertips. FinMkt’s solution includes dashboards and reporting tools to help you monitor how your financing program is performing. You’ll get visibility into approval rates, loan performance, and customer payment behaviors. All that rich data we talked about earlier – FinMkt helps you capture it and make sense of it, so you continuously improve your offerings. The data stays yours (it’s your captive program, after all), giving you an edge in understanding your customer base.
  
  
• Fast and seamless for your team and customers. FinMkt’s platform is designed to be user-friendly for everyone involved. Your internal team gets a simple portal to track applications, approvals, and funding status in real time. Customers can apply via a smooth online application (which you can embed on your site or send to their phone), and often get decisions in minutes. Everything from soft credit pulls that don’t hurt the consumer’s score (for pre-approvals) to e-signing the final loan documents is built in. This means offering financing won’t bog down your sales process; it will enhance it.
  
  
• Ongoing support and scalability. FinMkt doesn’t just drop the software in your lap and leave – they provide ongoing client support to help with any questions or issues. As you make loans, the platform can allocate those loans to different funding sources or even your balance sheet, using rules you set. In short, the solution is built to scale with your business. Whether you’re doing 10 loans a month or 1,000 loans, the same platform handles it.
  
  

From a practical standpoint, partnering with FinMkt for a captive lending program lets a home improvement contractor offer financing almost as if you were a bank, but without being a bank. You focus on your core business – making homeowners happy with quality renovations – and FinMkt powers the finance side behind the scenes. The result? More of your customers get approved financing (even as traditional banks make it hard), you close more sales, and you create a new income stream for your company. And importantly, you’re building loyalty: customers who finance through you will likely come back to you for future needs, since you’ve become their trusted one-stop solution.

Thriving in a Tight Credit Market

The financial landscape is constantly evolving. Right now, banks in the U.S. are cautious, grappling with losses and bracing for potential economic bumps ahead. That caution trickles down to consumers and businesses as tighter credit and fewer loan approvals. Home improvement contractors, who rely on customers being able to finance big projects, can feel stuck in the middle of this credit crunch. But as we’ve explored, there is a way to take control of the situation rather than be at its mercy.

Captive finance, once the realm of auto giants and big corporations, is now within reach for businesses of all sizes, thanks to fintech innovations. By embracing a captive lending program with the help of a platform like FinMkt, you can turn a challenging environment into an opportunity. Instead of seeing a customer get turned away by a bank (and your project slipping away), you can say, “No worries, we’ve got financing options right here for you.” That’s powerful. It builds trust with your customers – you’re providing a solution, not just a service – and it builds your business by removing a significant barrier to sales.

Of course, offering financing is a serious endeavor, and it should be done responsibly. You’ll want to ensure the loans offered are fair and affordable for your customers and that you’re managing risk appropriately. This is another area where FinMkt’s expertise is valuable: they’ve baked in risk assessment tools and compliance checks to protect you and your customers at every step.

In conclusion, the message is this: Don’t let the banks’ stricter lending stop your growth. You have the tools to adapt. By keeping financing in-house through a captive lending program, you sidestep the banks’ tight purse strings and elevate your business. Home improvement is a vast market (over $500 billion in annual spending in the U.S.), and projects will always be needed – the key is ensuring your customers have a way to pay for them that works. You can offer that way with a bit of creativity and the right partnership.

At the end of the day, helping homeowners achieve their dreams is what you do best. Offering captive finance extends help to the financial side of things. It’s about saying “Yes, we can make this happen for you” when others might say no. In a time when banks are saying “no” more often, yes will set you apart.

Financing doesn’t have to be a roadblock; it can be a cornerstone of your business strategy. Leveraging captive lender financing through a solution like FinMkt empowers your contracting business to thrive even when traditional lenders pull back. It’s a modern, proactive approach that keeps you in control of your customer relationships and revenue, no matter which way the economic winds blow.

So, as you plan to grow your home improvement business, consider this question: If the banks make it hard for your customers to get loans, could you become the lender they turn to? With FinMkt in your corner, the answer can be yes. We’ll all build success even in uncertain times by saying yes to projects, customers, and innovation.

‍